"*" indicates required fields

Subscribe

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy

Subscription Settings
Analysis

The Use of Force and the Trajectory of U.S.-Iran Talks

The May 9 edition of the Iran Media Review examines disagreements among Iranian media outlets about the effect of a Houthi missile strike targeting Israel on U.S.-Iranian negotiations.

Ali Alfoneh

7 min read

A May 4 missile strike on Israel’s Ben Gurion Airport by Yemen’s Houthi rebels does not appear to have significantly disrupted ongoing U.S.-Iranian diplomatic engagement, contrary to concerns voiced by reformist media outlets in Iran. This, in part, lends credence to the strategic calculus advanced by segments of the Iranian foreign policy elite who argued that calibrated use of force can serve as a means of coercive diplomacy to enhance Iran’s bargaining leverage. 

  • May 5: The reformist Ham-Mihan contextualized the Houthi missile strike within the broader framework of nuclear negotiations, asserting: 
    • “The impact of the missile strike on U.S.-Iran nuclear talks renders the situation acutely sensitive. While negotiations had seen modest momentum, recent developments suggest renewed vulnerability, with Israeli actors seizing any opportunity to derail the diplomatic track between Tehran and Washington. The attack on Ben Gurion Airport serves as a pretext for such sabotage.” 
  • May 5: In response, the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps-affiliated Mashregh News issued a rebuttal, framing Ham-Mihan’s analysis as ideologically and strategically flawed:  
    • “Once again, the reformist press aligns itself with Western narratives by attributing the autonomous decisions of the Yemeni resistance to Tehran. More troubling is the conditional logic that ties the success of indirect U.S.-Iran negotiations to the security imperatives of the Zionist entity. Why does Ham-Mihan employ Zionist terminology, and why does it, like Israel, lament a strategic blow delivered by the Yemeni axis of resistance?” 
  • May 5: Hard-line Kayhan, via its satire column, caricatured Ham-Mihan as “swooning into the embrace of America and Israel.”  
  • May 6: Ham-Mihan columnist Ahmad Zeidabadi responded, defending the newspaper’s editorial stance: 
    • “These guys behave as if possessed by evil spirits. They either don’t read our commentary or lack the cognitive capacity to grasp its content … More likely, they oppose negotiations with the United States in principle but, unable to declare this openly, redirect their opposition toward Ham-Mihan … It was not Ham-Mihan, however, that initiated engagement with Washington.” 
  • May 6: National security analyst Mehdi Kharatian, in an open letter addressed to Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi and disseminated via X, advocated for targeting international oil shipments to persuade the United States of Iran’s ability to disrupt international energy transportation. 
  • May 6: Mashregh News claimed U.S.-Iran negotiations were postponed due to “conflicts within the U.S. administration,” pointing at public disagreements between Donald Trump Jr. and the Foundation for Defense of Democracies. 
  • May 7: Former Supreme National Security Council Secretary Ali Shamkhani, on X, expressed optimism concerning resumption of the negotiations:  
    • “Washington has finally accepted the assessments of” the International Atomic Energy Agency “and its own intelligence agencies that Iran does not possess a nuclear weapon. Both parties are determined to continue the correct path of negotiations. The complete removal of sanctions and recognizing Iran’s right to industrial-scale enrichment bring an agreement within reach.” 
  • May 7: In an implicit rebuttal to Shamkhani on X, Mohammad-Hossein Ranjbaran, a media advisor to the foreign minister, cautioned against unauthorized disclosures:  
    • “Institutions and respected officials who are privy to classified intelligence must adhere to protocol and avoid disseminating sensitive information through affiliated media channels.” 

The views represented herein are the author's or speaker's own and do not necessarily reflect the views of AGSI, its staff, or its board of directors.

Ali Alfoneh

Senior Fellow, AGSI

Analysis

Iran Is Attacked, the Gulf Reacts

AGSI explains what Israel’s sudden and massive attack on Iran is likely to mean for Gulf Arab states, Iran, the United States, and global and regional economies.

34 min read

Smoke rises after an explosion in Tehran, Iran, Friday, June 13. (AP Photo/Vahid Salemi)

A Path to a Stronger United States in the Gulf

AGSI offers pragmatic, targeted policy recommendations for the Trump administration to maximize U.S. political and economic influence with the crucial emerging regional powers in the Gulf.

20 min read

President Donald J. Trump, fifth left, attends a group photo session with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, fourth right, UAE Crown Prince Khaled bin Mohammed bin Zayed al-Nahyan, second right, Bahraini Crown Prince and Prime Minister Salman bin Hamad al-Khalifa, left, Qatari Emir Tamim bin Hamad al-Thani, third left, Kuwaiti Emir Meshal al-Ahmed al-Jaber al-Sabah, second left, GCC Secretary-General Jasem Albudaiwi, right, during the GCC Summit in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, May 14. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

Supreme Oscillation: Khamenei’s Trump Strategy

Iran’s supreme leader is facing a strategic dilemma in how to pursue diplomacy with the United States and project strength amid internal fracturing and ambiguity.

Ali Alfoneh

23 min read

Iran Meets Elon

While any U.S.-Iran rapprochement could potentially ease sanctions on Iran, such a shift is poised to generate sharply divergent responses among U.S. allies.

Ali Alfoneh

10 min read

View All

Events

Jun 16, 2025

9:00am - 10:30am

Assessing Iranian, U.S., and Gulf Reactions and Options Following Israel’s Unprecedented Attack on Iran

On June 16, AGSI will host a discussion on Israel's attack on Iran.

Register
Rescuers work at the scene of a damaged building in the aftermath of Israeli strikes, in Tehran, Iran, June 13. (Majid Asgaripour/WANA via REUTERS)
Rescuers work at the scene of a damaged building in the aftermath of Israeli strikes in Tehran, Iran, June 13. (Majid Asgaripour/WANA via REUTERS)

Apr 29, 2025

The Real Deal? Are Washington and Tehran Closer to a Compromise?

On April 29, AGSI hosted a discussion on the U.S.-Iranian nuclear negotiations.

Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi, left, meets his Omani counterpart Sayyid Badr Al Busaidi prior to negotiations with Special Envoy to the Middle East Steve Witkoff in Muscat, Oman, Saturday, April 12. (Iranian Foreign Ministry via AP)
In this photo released by Iranian Foreign Ministry, Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi, left, meets his Omani counterpart Sayyid Badr Albusaidi prior to negotiations with U.S. Mideast envoy Steve Witkoff in Muscat, Oman, Saturday, April 12, 2025. (Iranian Foreign Ministry via AP)

Jul 11, 2024

In Conversation With Ali Alfoneh: Does Iran’s Presidential Election Matter?

On July 11, AGSIW hosted a discussion on Iran's presidential election.

People watch the debate of presidential candidates at a park in Tehran, Iran July 1, 2024. (Majid Asgaripour/ West Asia News Agency via REUTERS)
People watch the debate of presidential candidates at a park in Tehran, Iran July 1, 2024. (Majid Asgaripour/ West Asia News Agency via REUTERS)

Jan 9, 2024

2024 Outlook

On January 9, AGSIW hosted a virtual roundtable with its leadership and scholars as they looked ahead and assessed trends likely to shape the Gulf region and U.S. foreign policy during the coming year.

View All