"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Subscribe

By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy

Subscription Settings
Analysis

The US can live with the status quo, but Iran can’t

The brinkmanship exhibited at the nuclear negotiations between Iran and the P5 +1 international consortium is breathtaking, and suggests, for the first time in several months, the actual possibility of failure. There’s too much invested by all parties to make walking away appealing, but the United States reminding Iran that this remains a possibility emerged...

Hussein Ibish

5 min read

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry (L) and U.S. Under Secretary for Political Affairs Wendy Sherman (2ndL) wait at the start of a meeting with Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif (2ndR) in Vienna, Austria on June 30. (CARLOS BARRIA/AFP/Getty Images)

The brinkmanship exhibited at the nuclear negotiations between Iran and the P5 +1 international consortium is breathtaking, and suggests, for the first time in several months, the actual possibility of failure. There’s too much invested by all parties to make walking away appealing, but the United States reminding Iran that this remains a possibility emerged as a key factor last week.

Perhaps the most dramatic example of this was the American suggestion that the talks could simply continue on a lower-level and open-ended basis into the foreseeable future. The grounds for that would be an extension of the interim accord. This was a not particularly subtle way for the American side to say to the Iranian one: “We can live with the status quo a lot more easily than you can.”

After all, the interim accord provides very limited sanctions relief to Iran and yet commits Tehran to some significant measures to reduce its low-enriched uranium stockpile and other steps that roll back its nuclear programme.

At the same time, Iran has not been able to extricate itself from the diplomatic, industrial and financial box that the last wave of intense sanctions managed to construct. The American message was designed to remind Iran about the difficulties they continue to face as a result of the sanctions regime.

In the final analysis, Washington’s proposal in this regard is not serious. How could it possibly be in Iran’s interests to agree to make the interim agreement less temporary? It’s conceivable that they could agree to such an arrangement, but only to buy time. But there is simply no way that Tehran could live with the interim arrangement as a long-term formula.

This might well have played into the widely-reported and uncharacteristic outburst of anger by Iranian foreign minister Mohammad Javad Zarif who reportedly shouted at his interlocutors: “Never threaten an Iranian!” Most speculation focused on the heavy attention this remark got in Iran’s domestic media, suggesting that the whole thing was a play for public opinion. And certainly all sides are doing their best to try to look tough to assuage domestic hardliners.

But the possibility that the outburst was genuine and meaningful should not be dismissed. If it was, what was the threat in question? The major threat coming from the American side has to do precisely with the idea that the talks could be mothballed in favour of an indefinite extension of the interim agreement arrangements. And that would indeed be enough to make any Iranian diplomat lose his temper.

The American side has also been provoked of late by Iran’s demands that any nuclear agreement should also involve a lifting of the UN arms embargo. This suggestion didn’t provoke an outburst, but it did produce a strong reaction from the outgoing chairman of the US joint chiefs of staff, General Martin Dempsey.

He told a Congressional hearing that “under no circumstances should we relieve pressure on Iran relative to ballistic missile capabilities and arms trafficking,” seemingly ruling out any support for an American agreement to lift the embargo.

Russia and China, however, are reportedly strongly backing the new Iranian demand. This is hardly surprising, given that they are Tehran’s primary weapon suppliers. But it does mean that Iran has found a wedge issue dividing the P5+1 group, which has otherwise been surprisingly coherent across a variety of potentially difficult issues.

The Russians apparently also could not resist getting involved in the outrage game. “Or a Russian,” foreign minister Sergey Lavrov reportedly chimed in after Mr Zarif upbraided his interlocutors about threatening Iranians. The newfound Russian-Iranian common cause on not being threatened apparently came after European Union foreign policy head Federica Mogherini suggested that the talks might break down precisely because of Iran’s refusal to compromise on the arms embargo.

It’s entirely possible that Mr Zarif was basically playing tough for a domestic audience in preparation for unveiling an agreement that includes significant concessions to the West. But it’s also possible that his remarks, and those of Mr Lavrov, are actually public positioning in anticipation of a potential breakdown in negotiations. Either way, the uncharacteristic outbursts bear all the hallmarks of political manoeuvring before a major development.

It’s still far more likely that a deal will be achieved in the coming days than not, primarily because the core outlines of a deal were already laid down in the interim agreement: Iran will continue to enrich uranium but on a small scale and subject to intensive international inspections, in exchange for a lifting of sanctions. This would hold for 15 years, after which the issues would have to be revisited in some other context. Yet for both sides the devil is in the detail.

But as the United States has finally got around to reminding Iran in recent days, it can live with the status quo, including as laid out in the interim agreement, much more comfortably than Tehran can. And that ought to be enough to give the United States sufficient leverage to ensure that the details break largely in its favour. Or, everyone is now on notice, they really might just walk away after all.

This article originally appeared in The National.

The views represented herein are the author's or speaker's own and do not necessarily reflect the views of AGSI, its staff, or its board of directors.

Hussein Ibish

Senior Resident Scholar, AGSI

Analysis

Israeli Politics Can’t Address International, Especially Saudi, Concerns

Policies that prevent Saudi Arabia from pursuing diplomatic normalization and are fueling alienation in large parts of the West seem to reflect a Jewish consensus in Israel.

Hussein Ibish

16 min read

A tank mounted on a military truck passes an election campaign poster featuring Gadi Eisenkot, leader of the centrist Yashar party, in Kiryat Shmona, near the border with Lebanon in northern Israel, October 20. (AP Photo/Ariel Schalit)

Trump’s Impossible Dilemma: Return To War With Iran or Not?

President Trump has led the United States into an impossible dilemma in which resuming and intensifying the war presents one set of alarming consequences while ending it under current circumstances offers at least as many disasters for Washington.

Hussein Ibish

20 min read

People stand on a bridge destroyed after a strike in Hormozgan province, southern Iran, July 18. (Amirhosein Khorgooi/Iranian Students' News Agency via AP)

Will “Hormuz” be the American “Suez”?

The Trump administration has positioned the United States at a crossroads between a new regime of containment against Iran or a historic drawdown of U.S. influence in the Gulf and broader Middle East.

Hussein Ibish

18 min read

A satellite image shows the Strait of Hormuz, April 17. (EUROPEAN UNION/COPERNICUS SENTINEL-2/Handout via REUTERS)

Why Saudi Arabia and the UAE Are Urging Trump to Continue a War They Did Not Want

Riyadh and Abu Dhabi urged President Trump not to attack Iran, but now that the war is into its second month, leaving the current situation in place would be an unthinkable fiasco for them.

Hussein Ibish

8 min read

A black plume of smoke rises from a warehouse at the industrial area of Sharjah in the United Arab Emirates, March 1. (AP Photo/Altaf Qadri)
View All

Events

Nov 12, 2026

Israel’s Next Government and the Future of Relations With the Gulf

On November 12, AGSI will host a discussion on Israel's elections and the prospects for Israel's relations with the Gulf.

A pedestrian passes a campaign billboard featuring Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, left, and his main rival, opposition candidate Gadi Eisenkot, with a message in Hebrew that reads "The race is tight," October 23, in Tel Aviv, Israel. (AP Photo/David Goldman)
A pedestrian passes a campaign billboard featuring Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, left, and his main rival, opposition candidate Gadi Eisenkot, with a message in Hebrew that reads "The race is tight," October 23, in Tel Aviv, Israel. (AP Photo/David Goldman)

Nov 10, 2026

The New Wave in Washington: Navigating the Post-Midterm Landscape for Gulf-U.S. Relations 

On November 10, AGSI hosted a discussion on U.S.-Gulf relations after the midterm elections.

People arrive to watch results before Michigan Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed arrives at a Michigan Democratic Party election night event, November 3, in Detroit, Michigan. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)
People arrive to watch results before Michigan Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed arrives at a Michigan Democratic Party election night event, November 3, in Detroit, Michigan. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)

Nov 4, 2026

The Gulf Today: A Discussion in Memory of Aziz Alghashian

On November 4, AGSI and the Middle East Institute co-hosted a discussion on the state of the Gulf region.

Oct 28, 2026

Is the Houthi-Saudi Conflict the Start of a Broader Regional War?

On October 28, AGSI hosted a discussion on the connection between the Houthi-Saudi conflict and the Iran war.

A billboard displays portraits of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, Pakistan's army chief, Field Marshal Asim Munir, and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan following the signing of the Mecca Joint Defense Agreement, in Karachi, Pakistan, August 9. (REUTERS/Akhtar Soomro)
A billboard displays portraits of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, Pakistan's army chief, Field Marshal Asim Munir, and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan following the signing of the Mecca Joint Defense Agreement, in Karachi, Pakistan, August 9. (REUTERS/Akhtar Soomro)
View All